I think I am in the minority of fans of American Idol who are not upset at the addition of Ellen DeGeneres as judge, in place of Paula Abdul. When I heard the news this morning, I was ecstatic. Ellen is funny, coherent, and would easily replace the niceties to contestants that Paula was known to do. However, when I looked on my Blackberry and saw my favorite Idol commentator EW.com's Michael Slezak's excoriating response to the Ellen addition, I was nonplussed.
Michael noted that Ellen was exactly influential with her 'critiques' when she guest-judged the 99th episode of So You Think You Can Dance this past summer. However, I think that Ellen served her purpose for that job. She was probably invited to offer comic relief and it was purely a guest judging stint. I think she would approach American Idol a little differently.
Michael also noted that Ellen does not really come into the position with any real music industry know-how or experience. That is true, but no one on the panel is a Juilliard professor of music. The few critiques that Paula offered that made sense were never on point as far as tone or resonance that I can think of. American Idol, which I admittedly have a love-hate relationship with, is not all music. The winner is based on part personality, part song choice, part relatibility and a lot of other factors. You can't really say that about the winner of Project Runway or Top Chef, a show where the fans do not decide. In those cases, the judges should have firm backgrounds in the fields of fashion and food.
I agree with Michael that American Idol should really be about the contestants, but I think that Ellen will enforce that more than any of the current judges have done in the past. When she was on SYTYCD, she was funny but the biggest point she made of the night was about one of the dancers who Nigel Lythgoe really ripped right before her. Her comments resonated because you could tell that she wanted the dancer to know that he was special and deserved respect even if he wasn't necessarily the best or the most talented.
I just wish Ellen the best and I know she'll do a great job.